WorkPac ruling could hit retail sector

A recent Federal Court decision regarding the rights of casual workers in the mining industry could have implications for the retail sector, according to the National Retail Association, which says it opens a “can of worms”.

The Federal Court ruled that a casual truck driver employed by recruitment agency WorkPac was entitled to back pay for benefits such as annual leave because they had worked regular shifts for an extended period, despite being paid casual loading.

“Allowing casual employees to ‘double dip’ – whereby they receive higher wages while also accessing entitlements such as annual leave – has the potential to financially cripple many small businesses across several sectors,” NRA deputy chief executive Lindsay Carroll said.

“This is particularly true of some areas of the retail sector, such as fast food, which rely heavily on casual workers in periods of high customer demand.”

Carroll went on to push for the federal government to “close the loophole” to stop such issues arising in other industries, urging federal minister Kelly O’Dwyer and Opposition Leader Bill Shorten to back Australia’s small business community.

“Should the WorkPac precedent be extended to other industries, it would result in many mum-and-dad small businesses going down the plughole, along with thousands of jobs,” Carroll said.

Increased penalty rates to increase pressure on small businesses

The Fair Work Commission recently decided that casual workers will see higher penalty rates on Saturdays and weeknights as of November 1 – just in time for the busiest retail period of the year.

The Shop, Distributive and Allied Employees Association (SDA) national secretary Gerard Dwyer welcomed the decision, heralding it as a major win that would benefit hundreds of thousands of retail workers.

“This will result in significant pay increases for over 350,000 hard-working retail employees on the [Retail] Award and will have important flow effects for employees on enterprise bargaining agreements right across Australia’s retail sector,” Dwyer said.

However, the NRA slammed the decision to “slug Australia’s embattled retailers” with a wage hike so close to the busiest trade period of the year.

“At the moment, the money simply isn’t there to be asking small business owners to fork out more cash on wages,” NRA chief executive Dominique Lamb said.

With increased penalty rates, and the potential of claiming annual leave benefits as well, the cost of employing casual workers looks set to rise dramatically in the coming months.

Access exclusive analysis, locked news and reports with Inside Retail Weekly. Subscribe today and get our premium print publication delivered to your door every week.



  1. Mike posted on October 15, 2018

    What a joke this government and politics in general has become in Australia. Decisions such as the above will simply cost more jobs! I for one won't be opening over the January trading period and am in the process of restructuring my businesses to reduce the impost of ridiculous regulations such as the above. Whilst my turnover will reduce, my net profitability will increase and there will be less GST collected, fewer suppliers supported and fewer people employed as a result. I doubt this is the intended result the powers that be were looking for but ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!!!

  2. Bikram Balu posted on October 15, 2018

    So many businesses fail in Australia because of high overheads so why does rent and minimum wage go up every year???, am I dumb?, or is the system dumb?

Comment Manually


The worst case scenario for many retailers came to fruition on Monday afternoon, when Victorian Premier Daniel Andr…

4 days ago

Retail in Melbourne to be forced to close from 11:59pm this Wednesday. Contactless click-and-collect and online del…

5 days ago

Macca's stores around the world are getting a makeover. We go behind the scenes with the design agency that created…

5 days ago