Kmart vs Target

TARGETInside Shopper reader, Rebecca M, recently emailed me after having read my February article on Target West Lakes.

Rebecca waxed rhapsodic over her local Target at Frankston on the Mornington Peninsula in Victoria, so I had a poke around it last week, and then the Kmart in the same Bayside shopping centre for comparison. It was like night and day.

Below is a summary of what I found, but as usual, the pictures tell the real story. If range and price are the basics and the cost of entry in mass merchants, then here I will focus on customer experience, particularly the environment, entertainment, and to a lesser extent, simplicity elements of Dr AK Pradeep’s seven shopping experience dimensions.

TARGET IS LIGHT, WELCOMING, ALMOST PREMIUM WITH VALUE ADDED ELEMENTS

Impactful entry

The first thing you notice at store entry is the huge digital screen wall to the right displaying Missoni fashion, which had launched the day before. This is a step on from the freestanding entry digital sign at Target West Lakes.

To the left is a café with glamorous Hollywood style lighting to attract attention. The café ranges lesser known beverage brands and has a basic range of foodstuffs. At the time of my visit at 2pm on a Wednesday, it was full of mums with prams.

Target cafePremium Feel

The store is lit with LED downlights rather than fluoro and is very light and bright (and again, slightly more glamorous).

Some of the fixturisation, as in the lingerie area has a feel specific to that department. Confectionery has gone both fun and upmarket versus other mass merchants, with chocolate gift boxes lining the walls and local producer, Happy Lab, providing a more old fashioned lolly shop feel.

Myer and David Jones could learn from the changerooms here. Not only do they include seating areas, extra wide changeroom doors and premium light fixtures, but the lighting inside the changerooms themselves is soft and flattering. Finally!

Ease of navigation

Stock and signage is all low profile so you can see right across the store from the entrance. From the entry, five pathways radiate out across the store, the main one being the open runway through the middle of the store to the back wall, which has even fewer displays in it than West Lakes did, maintaining the open feel.

At the time of my visit the focus was on a series of jeans tables with low pricepoints to communicate value. Department navigation and signage has moved on from the blue His, pink Hers, turquoise Baby, and beige Home of West Lakes to the brightly lit Hollywood style signs, which are freestanding rather than being against the back walls, and feature lightboxes with product images, such as men’s shorts, for more subtle subcategory navigation.

Fixturisation has been thought through, with major display boxes against walls (‘wardrobes’ in Target parlance), for ambience and navigation and some with price pointed product to communicate value.

Value added services

A number of services have been added to this store. A garment alterations service is communicated in the changerooms, the sales point outside of the changerooms, and the services desk.

In the changerooms, you can use a ‘Changeroom Help’ call button service to have a Target staff member fetch you a different size or colour so you don’t have to re-dress and go running through the store to find it. This isn’t a revolutionary service, specialty fashion chains and the department stores theoretically do it, but it’s a level of service unusual for a mass merchant.

Custom t-shirt printing

Custom t-shirt printing

Custom T-shirt printing is available in the camera and photo section for $15+ per item (including the shirt), and store staff member Jemma tells me this is proving popular with local sports teams, although the capability of the service is as much for one off prints as for group designs. Shoppers can bring in their image in a variety of file types, on a USB stick or even on their smartphone and it is reproduced on a Target Essentials T-shirt. It will be interesting to see the level of take up of this service, as you pretty much have to be in the photo and entertainment section of the store to notice it.

Elements of discovery

There are some elements of the store where it appears the strategy is one of discovery, as they have either little or no signage:

  • Interactive floor projection for kids with multiple games including a piano keyboard you can jump on to make tunes, like in the movie Big with Tom Hanks
  • Interactive screen games, tablet style like a Microsoft Surface tablet and with a bench seat, are housed in an open cubby house underneath the Toys department sign
  • Online kiosks have the same signage as Price Check and confused me a bit. Perhaps the wording should be something like ‘order online’ and then separately  ‘price check’ to differentiate the two services. At any rate, these kiosks have the capacity for you to order online while in the store – helpful for bulky items such as large toys, or if your desired garment size or colour isn’t in stock. There were several of them in the store, although at time of visit they were down. Again not a revolutionary service, something that UK retailers such as John Lewis and New Look have been doing for several years, but a first for an Australian mass merchant
  • ‘Assisted ordering online’ at the back of the store at the click and collect desk was available as a computer screen, although its use wasn’t immediately clear because it wasn’t signed.

According to Rebecca M, “I definitely believe these little extras for kids attract families. The beauty of having child friendly and interactive areas was that the kids weren’t driving me crazy with their usual whingeing and wanting to leave. But on the flipside they really ‘didn’t want to leave’, which gave me ample time to notice a lot more merchandise than I normally would. My boy has a very active imagination, and even without the displays, the shopping experience was entertaining enough for him because he had a kiddie trolley to push.”

Perhaps some of these discovery elements could be called out more overtly if they are destinations for mums with kids.


Kmart frankstonKMART IS DARK, CRAMPED AND FEELS DOWN MARKET

To be fair, they were reshelving for Christmas, with decorations and trees etc, but this doesn’t excuse unboxed stock elsewhere in the store and papered over signage.

I can’t see where I’m going

This newer style Kmart features high departmental navigation signage which, however bright the colours used, ultimately has the opposite effect of what was intended. Right from the front entrance these high signs block visibility and interrupt sightlines.

I think I get what they are aiming for – ‘zones’ – but three sides of department signage per department creates walls and serves to make a zone feel boxed in and cramped, despite the colour.

In addition to the average visibility, pay points are a bit confusing – one central one in the middle of the store, and then a series of self checkouts upfront to one side, which felt like a bit of an afterthought.

kmart lingerieFixturing and ambience

Store lighting is dark, with basic fluoros running in lines along the ceiling contributing a factory-like feel, but not in an industrial chic way.

Fixturing is not consistent – Home vs others fixtures that have the bold colour stripes. Signage is amateurish – pricepoint bomb hanging signs papered over, but with no pricepoint; subcategory signage looked stuck on with Blu-Tak and likely to fall off. These looked like afterthoughts and not part of the fixture.

Interactivity and value adds in this store were non-existent and basically consisted of a few price check points scattered throughout the store.

Overall

To paraphrase Dragnet, ‘just the basics ma’am, just the basics’. The overall effect is down market, bordering on dingy. I was a bit surprised, as other Kmart stores (even the older formats) were better than this one. Simple improvements to lighting and lower fixtures would help.

IN SUM

The Target store was excellent and over delivers for a mass merchant/discount department store. It was welcoming, bright, friendly, easy to navigate, had sleek fixtures and signage, and felt more premium.

Kmart felt dark, cramped, and down market due to unboxed product everywhere and amateurish signage finishes. It will be interesting to see where Kmart takes its store design next and whether it will follow Target’s value added path or remain basic.

*Disclaimer: Author’s experience not necessarily representative of all stores in the chain as is based on that store on that day.   

Norrelle Goldring is head of shopper insight and retail strategy at global research and retail datahouse, GfK. Call Norrelle on 0437 335 686 or email norrelle.goldring@gfk.com.

target scrren

Target

Target lingerie

Target lingerie

Target frankston

Target changerooms

Target changerooms

taget menswear

Target meswear

Kmart signage

Kmart signage

Kmart home

Kmart home

 

 

Comments

10 comments

  1. Alastair posted on October 14, 2014

    A good comparison, however not completely accurate. The majority of Targets stores are still in the same structure as it has for 10 years, thus is like comparing a brand new car, when the majority of the fleet is over 10 years old.

    • Norrelle posted on October 14, 2014

      Thanks Alastair I like your analogy! Yes, the Target Frankston is the latest of their new store formats where my local Target in Carlingford for instance is old, small, pokey, poor lighting and checkout space and shows the difference between where they were and where they are heading. If it's anything like the new supermarket format rollouts, it'll take up to 4 years to get the whole fleet done. But I like to see where the game is going, not just where it's been!

  2. Richard posted on October 14, 2014

    Alastair - the article is only comparing two stores, so it is indeed accurate. It clearly says at the bottom that is it THAT store on THAT day. Obviously in time the "fleet" as you say will be upgraded to be that of the store today.

  3. Lorraine posted on October 14, 2014

    Perhaps Wesfarmers are deliberately segmenting the market - wouldn't it be smarter to include Woolworths Big W?

  4. Kate Kendall posted on October 14, 2014

    I have been following what is clearly a Target "Reinvention" for some 18 months and fascinated to see the many ways it is raising its bar to a higher level, in terms of stores, advertising, ranges. This may be one store on one day, but it is certainly indicative of a whole fresh management approach. Target is an Australian retail heritage and I'm delighted to see it such positive changes.

  5. Tony Curl posted on October 14, 2014

    I visited both companies new stores at Garden City and have to say that I believe Target has nailed it. Just the right mix of fashion and style and great price impact as well. The Kmart made me feel claustrophobic and totally confused by the central checkouts in Kmart. Not really sure what they are thinking there. Any way great comparisons of two new concepts.

  6. Darrell Wisbey posted on October 14, 2014

    Target and Kmart have been rivals for decades and both whilst active in the same retail segment have taken different approaches in their attempt to secure the top spot. In the 70's Target had a finger on the pulse and the heartbeat was strong .... look at the PBIT back in those days! Has anybody revisited the secrets to success back in that era and considered whether today they have simply lost connection with the basic retail drivers? From press announcements it is clear Kmart is resurrecting and Target have yet to show any worthwhile signs of a pulse on the life support system. Will watch with interest to see all the changes result in inspired customers spending with smiles.

  7. Senol posted on October 15, 2014

    Well done to Target. The store looks amazing!

  8. Maree Abbott posted on October 22, 2014

    This store is excellent, it's looks so bright, hassle free, it looks more like a department store with quality. Service is fantastic no waiting in line.

  9. frank posted on November 28, 2015

    Hi I print my own t shirts it costs me $12 to print a shirt and I sell them for $25 I guess im your competician. how do you print your t shirts so cheap? do you use heat transfers or a direct to garment printer? all the best Frank linehan

Comment Manually

Twitter

Last October, T2 moved into a stylish new HQ designed to boost teamwork and reflect its sustainability ethos. Then… https://t.co/dNout4TzDh

16 hours ago

Sportswear brand Lululemon has bought the in-home fitness company Mirror for US$500 million. Here's why. https://t.co/ClUk53W7KY #retail

1 day ago

Bardot has announced a new line of Australian-made denim. It's part of the fashion brand's aim to become more envir… https://t.co/g0v6sHCc4T

1 day ago